French luxury house Louis Vuitton Malletier secured a landmark first-instance trademark infringement victory in China against popular domestic beverage chain Molly Tea (Shenzhen Molly Tea Catering Management Co., Ltd.) and a local franchise outlet.
Issued by the Suzhou Intermediate People’s Court in Jiangsu Province, the judgment orders Molly Tea to immediately cease using its disputed geometric four-petal floral logo across storefronts, beverage cups, packaging, and digital platforms, pay RMB 10.3 million (~US$1.5 million) in economic damages and reasonable enforcement expenses, and publish formal corrective statements across six major Chinese social media and digital channels.
Key Highlights & Judicial Reasoning
The Suzhou court’s decision clarifies critical boundaries regarding figurative mark similarity, cross-class protection, and bad-faith commercial adoption in China:
- 1. Prior Registration & Cross-Class Coverage: Crucially, Louis Vuitton held valid prior Chinese trademark registrations for its iconic four-petal floral motifs covering Class 43 (restaurant and catering services), neutralizing the defense that a luxury fashion house and a milk tea chain operate in unrelated commercial sectors.
- 2. Continued Use After CNIPA Refusal: Prior to litigation, Molly Tea had applied to register its four-petal floral device mark in Class 43, which the China National Intellectual Property Administration (CNIPA) refused due to likelihood of confusion with Louis Vuittonβs cited registrations. Continuing to deploy the mark commercially across thousands of outlets after receiving official CNIPA refusal decisions demonstrated subjective fault and escalated damages.
- 3. Public Domain vs. Acquired Distinctiveness: While the defense argued that four-petal floral motifs draw on traditional Eastern aesthetic elements in the public domain, the court held that Louis Vuitton’s decades-long commercial use endowed its specific geometric execution with strong acquired distinctiveness and consumer recognition.
- 4. High Damages & Mandatory Public Rectification: Beyond the RMB 10.3 million monetary award, the court mandated public corrective notices on Weibo, WeChat, Xiaohongshu, Douyin, the brand’s website, and mini-program to dispel market confusionβthough Molly Tea has announced its intention to appeal.
Recommended IP Strategies for Brand Owners & Franchises
To safeguard brand equity and mitigate infringement risks when scaling across China and Asia:
Distinguish Cultural Inspiration from Registered Motifs: Creative teams drawing on traditional heritage aesthetics must ensure final commercial marks possess clear visual differentiation from famous registered trademarks.
Conduct Comprehensive Figurative & Device Searches: Clear not only brand names, but also geometric logos, floral motifs, and packaging layouts against registered device marks before rolling out store designs or franchise materials.
Heed CNIPA Office Actions Immediately: Treat trademark refusal decisions citing earlier prior rights as critical legal red flagsβcontinuing commercial use after a final refusal invites substantial statutory and punitive damages.
Build Defensive Multi-Class Portfolios: Global brand owners should register core house logos across adjacent lifestyle, hospitality, and F&B classes (such as Class 43) to block commercial free-riding early.
#ExyIntellectualProperty #ChinaIP #Trademarks #TrademarkLaw #BrandProtection #IPLaw

